I purchased the Physician's Formula Felt Tip Liner during the CVS 75% off beauty sale and I have to tell you that it went in the garbage can just last week. When I first got it home it was very moist and went on smooth. It did however attract eyeshadow like a magnet and after a few uses the tip was covered in shadow. I tried wiping it off after each use but it was not helping. After a few weeks it started to dry up. At that point I just gave up and threw it in the trash.
I would not repurchase this product and would give it 0 out of 5 sparkles.