These eye makeup remover wipes are awesome. They have a cooling feeling when I wipe them over my eyes and do a good job getting out all the mascara. I don't wear anything waterproof so I'm not sure how well it would work for that type of product. These wipes are very moist so the only downside of these is that when you rub off your makeup, you rub on a bunch of the remover solution. This doesn't bother me too much because it helps hydrate that area. When I get all the makeup off, I just take a tissue and wipe away the access remover. I found these at Target for around 5 dollars and there are 80 in the container. I think this is a great deal since I used to use the ELF ones. My target does not carry very many ELF products so the only way I would be able to repurchase was to order online. The ELF eye makeup remover wipes were very moist with remover but I felt they left my skin dry. I also thought the ELF wipes felt like they had more alcohol than the Almay ones. The Almay wipes also smell a lot better than the ELF ones since they contain cucumber.
Overall I would give this product 3 out of 5 sparkles.