Swatched with no primer. The Almay shadows are on the left and the corresponding Wet n Wild shade is on the right.
Both shades of green in these pallets are very similar. What I like most about the Wet n Wild pallet is the purple. It is much more intense and pigmented compared to the Almay one.The reason I bought the Wet n Wild pallet was because I was so disappointed with the performance of the Almay one (with or without a primer). I'd say Wet n Wild wins this battle.